What Modern Trade can Learn from Mom & Pop (Kirana)

-
Enough has been said about the FDI in retail (in India). And my views are very clear. I also strongly believe that the Indian players can stand the might of MNCs and infact capitalize on the efficiencies which these MNCs will bring to the table.
For the uninitiated, kiranas are shops that cater to the regular needs of food, grocery and also products like paan, cigarettes etc. within a locality/catchment area. There are also others like the headload and pushcart vendors.

Globally, as modern trade expanded, both organised retail players and unorganised retail participants have co-existed. The Walmarts and Costcos have co existed with the mom and pop stores (in India these are  called kiranas). I do believe that there is no reason why it cannot co-exist here in India.

However there are a few factors apart from systemic deficiencies which have worked in the favor of kiranas or the local store owner/vendor. 

Personalized service
  • Personal/ social touch
    • Ashraff, the person who runs our neighbourhood store knows all our family - where we stay, what we buy and our tastes. There is friendly banter and a relationship not just based on transactions. If he is free, he will discuss with you, the issues in the area and also about his family. When shopping ceases just to be transactional and more social, then the relationship has moved to the next level. Shopping becomes more a social activity rather than a mundane one. 
  • Knowledge of buying habits
    • Ashraff has a pulse on the consumer behaviour in our area.  He has a detailed understanding of consumers’ shopping preferences and habits - he knows what will sell, who will buy it and even at times when they will buy it. Even if a product is not available he will ring up the distributor and then tell you when he will get it. This level of knowledge is something modern trade needs to obtain. Analytics etc. are tools to facilitate this and while I do think it will be difficult to replicate in modern trade, a fair degree can be reached.
Daily top ups
Kiranas meet the needs of consumers who need to do daily top-ups of select food and grocery items. While the variety will be limited by virtue of size, kiranas keeping track are able to supply the daily and immediate needs. Modern retail formats offer the ability/ facility to buy several SKUs under one roof, but facilities do not exist to supply the customer daily/ immediate needs. The system needs to be re-engineered to work around this.

Order through telephone 

Given the proximity and relationship, we can call Ashraff and ask him for the products we want. We do not need to go physically there.

Home delivery
Within some time, we will have what we asked for at our doorstep. This kind of service endears us to the kirana. The convenience is unparalleled and sees us avoiding a lot of time and trouble to get the products home.  Modern trade can surely steal a page out of Ashraff's notebook and replicate with modifications ofcourse!

Credit
Ashraff allows us to pay once a month. I don't have to take my wallet each and every time. Actually he is smart, since I don't pay immediately, I end up purchasing much more than I require. A gentle upsell!


There are certain aspects which large departmental stores cannot replicate and hence there will always be a necessity for kiranas. The best which modern trade can do is to customize their services taking the key learnings from kiranas with the hope that the twain shall meet someday.

Comments

Rohit Verma said…
Hi Vejay,

I have been hearing this debate from few years now specifically in IT Retail market. Fear that mom & pop shops will not be able to survive in front of organized retail.
I have been saying since the time LFR came to India that both will co-exist. There are lots of reasons:
Personal touch
Able to negotiate
Support
Friendly advise
Trust & Confidence

I think LFRs have to work a lot and say learn as mentioned by you from these guys...

Rohit
December 28, 2011 at 4:57 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Curiosity Never Killed the Cat - In Memory of T C K Menon

-
Most of you do not know my uncle. T.C. Krishnankutty Menon (TCK), or to me Aniyanmaman, passed away recently.  He resided in Trichur, in God's Own Country,  a town more famous for its literary figures, jewellers, temples and Pooram. I was born there and he stayed in a house next to ours - we were all from the same family. TCK was, in a sense, a true blue Keralite. He did his schooling in Trichur followed by his graduation in Chemistry at Maharaja's College, Ernakulam, quickly followed by a post-graduation through research. He joined Sri Kerala Varma College, Trichur after that, in two spells and taught there till his retirement. In-between he did drop into the Indian Agricultural Research Institute, Delhi for his Ph.D but for reasons which lie buried with him, he returned to Trichur and that's where he stayed for the rest of his life. His visits out of Kerala were few and far. A Keralite he was but parochial he was a not. In a small town not really conducive to the
Read more

Flying Just Above the Ground - Thoughts on the Airline Industry Ecosystem

-
The airline industry in India has been going through an enormous amount of pain. It has seen more downs than ups. At a time when the economic outlook is far better than the US or European geographies, the whole business is going through a crisis of sorts; some due to its own doing and some due to extraneous factors. Market In recently announced statistics, the domestic market has increased 1.1% year-on-year in Mar-2012 to 4.87 million passengers. This is the slowest month of domestic passenger growth since May-2009 when passenger levels declined 4.4%. Passenger traffic increased 6.55% in 1Q2012 to 15.3 million. For 34 consecutive months the market has seen growth however it is the third month in the same period which has seen a single digit growth. There has been 16 months of double digit growth prior to that. The drop in traffic can be directly attributed to the reduction in coverage by Kingfisher Airlines. Till such time, India's growth rate was among the highest
Read more

Hype ? - about Hyperlocal Grocery

-
Image
At around $350 billion, India is in the top grocery markets of the world.  This is approximately 70% of the Indian retail business which is around $500 billion. Modern retail accounts for 10 - 20% of this pie.  E-commerce or hyperlocals are obviously a tiny part of the pie just yet. Most companies, therefore, are still at a stage where they have to prove their business models and change consumer behaviour. These type of businesses are expected to reach around 2% of the grocery market by 2020, creating a potential market size of around $10 billion (Rs 60,000 crore). The hyperlocal on demand grocery has mainly two models - a) A large player like Big Basket offering localised services. Inventory is carried by the company. b) An aggregator using the local retailers to source products and handling the delivery c) An aggregator using local retailers to stock and deliver It is a no-brainer that an aggregation model, as it is asset-light, is less capital-intensive than the inventory-
Read more